| Operating principle | Gravity separation: screening and flotation, with no chemical change to the matrix. | Colloid destabilization by purchased reagents, followed by precipitation. | Organic matter digestion by an anaerobic consortium, with biogas generation. | Biological oxidation under forced aeration, in suspended or attached biomass. | Oxidation by ozone, UV or peroxide; membrane rejection; adsorption on carbon. | Double conversion under variable-frequency alternating current: coagulant and oxidant generated in situ, with hydroxyl radical production. |
|---|
| Treatment stages covered | Preliminary and primary. | Primary; polishing. | Secondary. | Secondary; nitrification. | Tertiary; disinfection. | Secondary, tertiary, disinfection, reuse and recovery — in a single module. |
|---|
| Removed parameters | Coarse and settleable solids; free oil and grease. | TSS, colloidal fraction, phosphorus, metals, color. | BOD; partial COD; solids. | BOD, COD, ammonia N, TSS. | Micropollutants, color, pathogens. | COD, BOD, total N and P, surfactants, sulfides, TOG, TSS, color, metals. |
|---|
| Detention time▼lower is better | Minutes; 1 to 2 h with a primary clarifier. | 20–60 min, across mixing, flocculation and separation. | 6–10 h, plus a secondary clarifier. | 6–24 h, plus a secondary clarifier. | 15–60 min, on already treated effluent. | Under 5 min in complex effluent — two orders of magnitude below the biological routes. |
|---|
| Organic load removal efficiency▲higher is better | BOD 5–10%; 25–40% with a primary clarifier. Does not reach the dissolved fraction. | COD 30–70%; BOD 50–80% and TSS 80–90% with continuous dosing. | BOD 60–75%, COD 55–70% — the legal minimum, with no extra margin. | BOD 85–95%, COD 85–90% — the industry reference. | COD 40–70%, on the residual upstream load. | COD 87.8–99.7% (94.4% average on raw sewage); BOD 99.0–99.6% on the described matrices. |
|---|
| Nutrient removal (N and P)▲higher is better | None. | Phosphorus 80–95% by precipitation; nitrogen 20–25%. | Practically none; converts organic N into ammonia. | 25–30% without a dedicated stage; effective removal requires nitrification, denitrification and chemical dosing. | Partial, depending on the process adopted. | N 34.7 → < 1.1 mg/L and P 6.5 → < 1 mg/L in the campaigns, with no precipitating reagent and no dedicated stage. |
|---|
| Admissible matrix envelope▲higher is better | Indifferent to composition. | Broad, subject to redosing. | Narrow: pH 6.5–7.5; sulfides and metals are inhibitors. | Narrow: C:N:P ratio, salinity and toxicity are limiting. | Requires a stable upstream load. | Declared envelope for produced water: salinity up to 50,000 mg NaCl/L, pH 3 to 10, H₂S up to 4,000 ppmv, TOG up to 1,000 mg/L; high conductivity is functional to the process. |
|---|